Montauk recommendations: where to eat, drink and go in Montauk, NY

17 places in Montauk, NY that creators on TikTok, Instagram and YouTube have posted about. Each one comes with what people say about it.

  1. Montauk Lighthouse

    Visit this historic coastal landmark for its rugged shoreline beauty, but be mindful of the heavy summer tourist traffic.

  2. Sushi | Bar Montauk

    Experience an intimate 17-course omakase set against stunning oceanfront views featuring luxury ingredients flown fresh from Japan.

  3. Left Hand Coffee

    A Montauk cafe offering specialty coffee drinks with macadamia nut milk for an ideal eastern Long Island stop.

  4. Bennett Shellfish

    A charming local seafood stand renowned for serving exceptionally fresh lobster rolls and local clams.

  5. Memory Motel

    Experience a nostalgic cinematic journey by visiting this iconic landmark known for its famous sign and rich pop culture history.

  6. Bird on the Roof

    Visit Montauk for a top-tier brunch experience featuring great food and service in a popular coastal destination.

  7. Barlume Beach Restaurant

    Waterfront beach club offering a vibrant summer ambience with house music and scenic seaside dining.

  8. Hither Hills General Store

    Experience creative NYC pop-ups featuring a signature matcha uniquely topped with crunchy cornflakes and strawberries.

  9. Montauk Point Lighthouse Museum

    Experience a historic landmark offering sweeping ocean views and rocky coastal beaches at the eastern tip of Long Island.

  10. John's Drive-In

    Nostalgic Montauk staple serving homemade ice cream and classic fare, though visitors must navigate high Hamptons costs and logistics.

  11. Alba Spiaggia

    Experience a vibrant Italian eatery at the Montauk Yacht Club featuring signature orecchiette despite complex reservation logistics.

  12. Navy Beach Restaurant, Montauk | Seafood Restaurant

    A scenic beachfront destination offering stunning sunset views over Fort Pond Bay, best enjoyed with a sunset picnic and drinks.

  13. Shadmoor State Park

    Scenic coastal park offering an easy 10-minute hiking trail paired with dramatic ocean cliff views and scenic beaches.

  14. Montauk

    An elevated abandoned rail spur perfect for beginner urban exploration and creative photography projects.

  15. Duryea's Lobster Deck

    Enjoy scenic waterfront dining in a relaxed deck setting, famous for serving massive king crab platters and fresh raw bar seafood.

  16. The Crow's Nest

    Experience a picturesque sunset at this rustic lakeside retreat, which is currently trending due to its charismatic Argentine host.

  17. Marram

    Experience a serene coastal atmosphere at this minimalist hotel, featuring chic wood-paneled architecture and unique complimentary cruiser bikes for local exploration.